Scrupulosity & Religious OCD | Christian Psychologist

Psychological Support for Scrupulosity

Are you feeling consumed by doubts about your faith, constantly worried you've sinned, or seeking repeated reassurance about your moral or spiritual standing?

You may be experiencing scrupulosity, a form of OCD that can cause deep anxiety around religious or ethical beliefs. Support is available. Therapy can help you understand what’s happening, reduce the distress of obsessive thoughts and compulsive behaviours, and create space for a more peaceful, grounded relationship with your values and beliefs. Freedom from relentless guilt and fear is possible—with the right support, healing can begin.

Book An Appointment

“It’s okay if you’re tired of trying to make sense of it all. You don’t have to do it alone.”

Information about Scrupulosity

What is Scrupulosity

Scrupulosity is a form of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) that involves persistent, distressing thoughts or fears about being morally or spiritually wrong. While it’s common for people of faith to reflect on their values and choices, scrupulosity goes beyond healthy self-reflection. It leads to intense anxiety, excessive guilt, and repeated attempts to gain certainty about one’s spiritual state or moral standing.

People experiencing scrupulosity often worry excessively about being sinful, offending God, or failing to live up to spiritual or ethical standards. These thoughts are distressing and persistent—and no amount of reassurance or religious practice seems to provide lasting relief. Scrupulosity is not a reflection of weak faith or character, but a mental health concern that deserves compassionate support.

Individuals with scrupulosity may experience:

Intrusive thoughts about sinning, blasphemy, or displeasing God
Constant fear of doing something wrong without realising it
Repeated prayer or confession rituals to feel “clean” or forgiven
Avoidance of spiritual practices due to fear of doing them incorrectly
Difficulty feeling spiritually assured, no matter how much effort is made

Despite the spiritual content of these thoughts, scrupulosity is not a reflection of weak faith. It is a recognised mental health condition where the mind becomes caught in cycles of doubt and reassurance-seeking. Treatment is available—and effective.

How is Scrupulosity Treated?

Effective treatment for scrupulosity requires an approach that respects an individual’s spiritual beliefs while helping reduce the anxiety and compulsive patterns that fuel OCD. Below are three therapeutic approaches that can be particularly helpful:

Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP)

ERP is the most researched and widely recommended treatment for OCD, including scrupulosity. In ERP, individuals gradually face the thoughts, images, or situations that trigger their fear (exposure), while refraining from engaging in compulsive behaviors such as repeated prayer, confession, or mental checking (response prevention).

For scrupulosity, ERP might involve:

Sitting with the uncertainty that one may have prayed “incorrectly”
Choosing not to repeat a confession or seek reassurance
Allowing the discomfort of not knowing with 100% certainty whether one sinned

Over time, this process helps break the cycle of anxiety and compulsion, restoring a more peaceful and trusting approach to faith and morality.

Inference-Based CBT (I-CBT)

I-CBT addresses the reasoning style behind obsessive doubt. In scrupulosity, this might involve recognising how a person arrives at a conclusion like, “Because I had a bad thought, I must have sinned,” even without any real evidence.

I-CBT helps individuals:

Understand the difference between imagined scenarios and real spiritual risk
Reconnect with reality-based thinking instead of trying to “solve” every doubt
Reduce the need for mental rituals by challenging the obsession at its root

This approach can be especially helpful when someone feels they need to "figure out" whether they are right with God before they can move forward.

Schema Therapy

Schema Therapy explores deeper emotional patterns that may contribute to scrupulosity, such as fears of punishment, a deep need for perfection, or a belief that one is fundamentally flawed or unworthy.

This approach may be helpful for individuals who:

Grew up in highly rigid or fear-based religious environments
Struggle with deep guilt, shame, or spiritual unworthiness
Experience coexisting difficulties in relationships, self-esteem, or identity

Schema Therapy works by identifying and healing these longstanding beliefs, fostering a healthier self-understanding and a more grace-filled relationship with faith.

What are the Symptoms of Scrupulosity?

Obsessions in Scrupulosity

Obsessions in scrupulosity often involve intrusive thoughts, images, or urges related to:

Fear of sinning unintentionally (e.g., “What if I lied without realising it?”)
Fear of offending or displeasing God
Excessive concern about blasphemy, impure thoughts, or spiritual failure
Fear of going to hell or being spiritually condemned
Excessive worry about moral decisions or ethical ‘grey areas’
Intrusive doubts about salvation, forgiveness, or one's standing with God
Fears related to religious practices being done incorrectly or without sincerity

These thoughts are typically unwanted, distressing, and not aligned with the person’s true beliefs or intentions. Individuals often recognise that the thoughts are irrational but feel unable to dismiss them.

Compulsions in Scrupulosity

To try to manage or neutralise these distressing thoughts, individuals may engage in compulsive behaviours—either outwardly or mentally. These are done in an attempt to gain certainty or feel “clean,” “forgiven,” or “right” with God.

Common compulsions may include:

Repeatedly praying for forgiveness, often in a rigid or exact way
Confessing sins frequently or repeatedly, even for minor or imagined offences
Seeking reassurance from religious leaders, friends, or scripture
Avoiding certain words, images, or settings considered “impure” or spiritually risky
Re-reading religious texts or repeating verses until they feel “just right”

Mental Compulsions

Many compulsions in scrupulosity happen internally. These mental rituals are often invisible to others but can be exhausting and time-consuming.

Examples of mental compulsions include:

Silently repeating prayers or verses to “cancel out” a bad thought
Mentally reviewing one’s actions to check for sin
Trying to “prove” or reassure oneself that they are right with God
Replaying conversations or events to ensure no wrong was done
Engaging in debates with oneself about theology, morality, or forgiveness

These compulsions often provide only brief relief before the cycle of doubt returns.

When Faith Becomes Entangled with Fear

Scrupulosity can deeply affect a person’s sense of peace, joy, and connection with their faith. What was once a source of comfort can begin to feel like a source of fear, guilt, or confusion. It’s not uncommon for people experiencing scrupulosity to feel spiritually stuck, ashamed, or uncertain about how to move forward.

Seeking Psychological Support for Scrupulosity

You don’t have to walk through this alone. Support from a psychologist who understands both OCD and the role of faith in a person’s life can be incredibly helpful. With the right care, individuals can learn to differentiate between genuine spiritual conviction and obsessive doubt—and begin to reconnect with their faith in a way that brings peace rather than fear.

Kylie Walls is a registered psychologist with an interest in helping individuals experiencing religious or moral OCD, including scrupulosity. Kylie can help you understand what’s happening and work toward peace of mind.

Kylie works sensitively with clients navigating faith-related distress, offering evidence-based therapy in a space that respects your spiritual values and beliefs.